Page 1 of 1

DebateAnAtheist - Ruleset Survey

Rule 1 - Be Respectful (choose all that apply)

*

Define specific behaviors that constitute actionable disrespect

Have a set escalation schedule

Have no set escalation schedule (leave it to moderator discretion)

Abstain

Rule 2 - No Bigotry (choose all that apply)

*

Delete this proposed rule

Define specific types of bigotry that are not tolerated

State that bigotry will result in an immediate and permanent ban

Allow for escalation (leave it to moderator discretion)

Have a set escalation schedule

Abstain

Rule 3 - AI Content (choose one)

*

A

Prohibit all AI/LLM content

B

Prohibit generative AI/LLM content, allow other types of AI

C

Allow AI under certain circumstances

D

Abstain

Rule 4 - Original Content (choose all that apply)

*

Delete this rule

Allow up to 1/3rd of the text to be non-original content (quotations and/or links)

Allow a different percentage of the text to be non-original content

The substantive argument in a post must be in the poster's own words

Abstain

Rule 5 - Present an Argument/Discussion Topic (choose one)

*

A

Allow only arguments

B

Allow arguments and discussion topics, if correctly flaired

C

Allow arguments and discussion topics, if correctly flaired, and discussion topics must explain how the user feels genuinely uncertain

D

Abstain

Rule 6 - Stay On Topic (What do you consider on-topic? Choose all that apply)

*

Theism

Atheism

Religion in general

Secular topics in general

Philosophy

Evolution/abiogenesis

Creationism

Other topics that are clearly connected to atheism

For posts: Topics that question or challenge atheism/atheists

Abstain

Rule 7 - Substantive Top Level Comments (choose all that apply)

*

Keep the minimum top level comment length at 30 characters

Change the minimum top level comment length to a different number of characters

Top level comments must engage substantively with the post

Allow top level comments that seek clarification from the original poster

Abstain

Rule 8 - Engage With Posts (choose one)

*

A

The poster must substantively engage within 1 hour

B

The poster must substantively engage within 6 hours

C

The poster must substantively engage within 12 hours

D

The poster must substantively engage within 24 hours

E

Use a different time limit

F

Abstain

Any additional rules you would like to see included? Type "Abstain" to abstain. You can also use this space for general comments.

*